HSN Deal Today Only, and a Comparison of TracFone and Straight Talk

A couple of people have alerted me to a deal that might interest many people. (Thank you to Chris, JLL, Dorothy, and Kelly for taking the time to share this deal with me either via comments, or the “about” page.)

HSN is selling the TracFone LG 500g with Triple Minutes for Life (life of the phone), along with 1300 minutes, for $100. This deal is apparently valid for today only (Saturday, July 30, 2011), so you’ll need to act quickly to take advantage. Click here to find that deal.

The LG 500g (click here for the review page) is a solid basic phone with a QWERTY keyboard and mp3 player, among other features. And even ignoring the value of the phone itself and the TMFL benefit, 1300 minutes for $100 is a pretty good deal (a rate of 7.7 cents per minute). So I think this is a very good deal if you’re in the market for this type of phone.

I also thought it was worth considering the value of TracFone compared to Straight Talk at this point. One commenter, “marcopolish,” asked how these two services stacked up, so I decided to do a little analysis using the TMFL TracFone against Straight Talk’s $30 plan. Here’s what I came up with:

It’s tough to compute a break-even point above which Straight Talk is a better value, since different people will use different ratios of talk/text/data. Really, if you’re talking a lot, or texting a lot, or browsing a lot, or some combination thereof, Straight Talk is going to be a better value. But let’s look a little more closely anyway.

Just for example, let’s say you bought TracFone’s 1500-minute bundle – available only from Tracfone.com – and added it to a TMFL phone. The cost is $200, and the minutes are good for a year. Assuming these 1500 minutes will triple (which they should, since they do indeed double on DMFL phones), you’ll get 4500 minutes to use over the course of a year. This averages to 4.444 cents per minute (ignoring sales tax).

Now let’s compare that to Straight Talk’s $30 plan. Let’s say you had $30 to spend on your cell plan each month. If you were buying TracFone airtime at 4.444 cents per unit, you’d get 675 minutes (to be split between talk and text). But if you instead spend that $30 on Straight Talk, you’d get 1000 minutes, 1000 texts, and 30mb of texts.

So in this analysis, assuming TRIPLE minutes for life, the break-even point is somewhere around 675 units per month. Figure that a text counts as half a minute, since that’s the rate charged on the LG 500g in this HSN example. So the 675 figure might also be calculated as 500 minutes and 350 texts, or 200 minutes and 950 texts, etc. If you’re using more airtime than that, you’ll save money by going with Straight Talk. But this can all change depending on what denomination of card you buy, whether you have Double or Triple for life, and how you use your minutes.

I hope you’ve been able to follow along with my math. If you have a different analysis of which is a better deal, I’d love to hear about. Please let me know about it in the comments section below this post.

LG 501c Review – Part 1

For the LG 501c review, I’ve once again called on my old TracFone friend Otis226 to share his thoughts. The review below is largely his work, with some minor edits and/or additions by myself (pbushx2). I have gone through the review completely myself, and believe the work to be completely reliable and consistent with my own experiences with the LG 501c. So, here’s the first part of the review from Otis226. As more segments of the review are posted, you’ll find links to them on this LG 501c review index page.

LG 501c Review

LG 501c Review Picture 1Pbushx2 has again kindly permitted me to put down my thoughts on the LG 501c (available for both TracFone and Net10), so I’d like to offer this review of the handset. One of the biggest pluses this, or any other newly released Tracfone can have for me is a full users manual, and this handset indeed has one available. Although it doesn’t answer every question that will come up when you start using your phone, to me, it is so much better than the trial and error methods needed for models that Tracfone decides to release with a 1 or two page ‘quick start guide’ only. That may be my age showing, but I know I’m not the only person ‘over 50’ to use Tracfones who appreciates a real users manual.

General Overview

This is the first Tracfone offered in CDMA version using a full QWERTY keyboard (The LG500g, which was reviewed earlier on this blog, was the GSM version). As Patrick has mentioned earlier, this phone is very similar in appearance to the 500g.

Dimensions are 4.5 x 2.3 x 0.5 inches, with a weight of 2.83 oz. My initial impression was that it felt just a bit thicker than the 500g, and the color of the sides and back are more gray than black. I’ll mention the other slight physical differences as I describe the general appearance.

This phone does come with the DMFL option from Tracfone. Unlike the LG500g, there is no memory slot, mp-3 player or video capabilities with this phone. It does have bluetooth connectivity as well as a VGA (0.3 megapixel) camera on board however.

In my reviewing its features, I’ve found it fairly comparable to the older LG290c slider phone, which I still use as my everyday Tracfone. The lighter weight, qwerty keyboard and full bluetooth connectivity are pluses for the LG501c. Having the capability to disable the browser on the LG290c is a big plus in its favor for this user. The browser button cannot be disabled with the 501c.

The “reserved memory” provides room for up to 1,000 contacts, 300 calendar events, 100 notes, (each note is limited to 150 characters), and 150 entries in call history. A total of 700 messages can be stored, (500 SMS, 100 MMS, and 100 MMS notifications). The internal ‘multimedia’ memory of this phone is limited to 73.1 mb out of the box, as some of the total 75mb appears to be allocated the the “reserved memory described above.

Two other features that are a bit disappointing compared to the LG500g; the record voice feature allows you use ‘pause’ while recording, but not when playing back the recording, as you can on the 500g. I used this record feature quite a bit with the 500g to dictate notes, since pausing the playback was so convenient. Also, the alarm function will not work with the phone switched off, as on the 500g. On this model, the phone needs to be powered up for the alarm to work.

External/Appearance

This phone feels about as good in the hand as the LG500g did to me. It slides into and out of a pocket pretty easily. The rounded edges help that a lot. I have not dropped this phone yet, as the finish on the edge of the device seems to be more of a “matte” finish as opposed to the glossiness on the 500g, thus making for a better gripping surface.

In terms of quality of construction, I feel it is certainly as well made as the LG500g, or any of the other recent Tracfones I’ve handled. I think most users would not feel the same stigma that some experienced with the earlier Tracfones, which seemed to announce they were inexpensive pre-paid phones.

The LG logo is just under the screen in front and is embossed on the back cover as well. The Tracfone swirl logo is only found on the back cover, under the camera lens. Two speaker slots are just to the left of the lens.

On the top edge is a covered 2.5mm audio jack, as opposed to the more commonly used 3.5mm jack on the 500g. (Of course without an mp-3 player on the 501c, this may not be a big deal to most people). The charge port is located on the left upper edge and on the right side are the external volume keys.

The screen shows the typical Tracfone info: signal strength, amount of battery charge, date and time, (after the handset is activated). It also displays when the phone is in ‘home’ or ‘roam’ areas, and can display the number of minutes and service days left. There is an icon glossary located in the settings sub-menu if something should be unfamiliar to you on the screen.

From left to right, the fixed keys are; menu, camera, 4-way directional pad, clear and browser key. Below these are the ‘send’ and power end/keys. The directional keys don’t look to be programmable. The shortcuts assigned to each key are as follows: up = messages menu, left = games menu, down = contacts list, and right = sound menu.

As with the 500g, I initially felt that the ‘qwerty’ keys would be too small to be effectively used by my large hands, but I find typing on the little keypad better than expected. We’ll get into further features in the next part of the review.

Also in the next portion of the review, we’ll get into the audio quality, signal reception, the keypad and menus. Before part 2 is published, though, I’ll also have the first part of Samsung t528g review underway.

TracFone

Net10

Intro Review Videos – Samsung t528g, Motorola EX124g, and LG 501c

A little over a week ago I got several new phones all in a short time frame, and just recently finally got the intro/unboxing videos edited and uploaded at the end of last week. Here’s a rundown of the videos I recorded when I opened the phones. All the videos are pretty lengthy, so I won’t say much in the way of introduction. But I can tell you that I’m working on the Samsung t528g review next, followed by the EX124g.

Samsung t528g Review Video 1:

Motorola EX124g Review Video 1:

LG 501c Review Video 1:

Nokia E5 Now Available

Nokia E5 is now available from Straight TalkI just wanted to take a minute here to let you know that Straight Talk now has the Nokia E5 (sometimes called the Nokia E5g) available on their site in GSM (AT&T) areas. It is also apparently available in some Walmart locations, although I was unable to find it in my area stores.

This phone is very similar to the Nokia E71 from November of 2010, with a few upgrades. A few of the differences include a better camera and faster processor on the newer phone.

There are a few areas where the E5 looks like a step back, though, as I pointed out in this previous Nokia E5 intro post. So if you are considering buying this phone, I suggest taking a look back at that post where I went over some of the key differences between the Nokia E71 and the E5.

One key similarity is that the E5, like the E71 and Nokia 6790 before it, is available ONLY with Straight Talk’s $45 unlimited plan. If you are interested in any of these phones, you can check out more details at Straight Talk’s site.

More Phone Reviews

Also, I recently recorded some “unboxing” videos for the Motorola EX124g (Net10 and TracFone), the LG 501c (Net10 and TracFone), and the Samsung t528g (Straight Talk). I’ll post those videos shortly, and I’m working on the written reviews as well. Stay tuned for all of that.
TracFone

Net10

Straight Talk

TracFone Deals and Triple Minutes

I’ll soon have some unboxing videos to share with you, and I’ve started reviews for these phones, but I’ve also got some timely info this week. Two different TracFone handsets are on sale right now.

The first is the TracFone LG 500g QWERTY from Target (brick and mortar store only, not available online). There you can get this phone for $20, which is $5 cheaper than you’d pay at TracFone.com after using the discount code. For the LG 500g review, click here. This deal is available through Saturday.

Next, the LG 290c, a CDMA slider, is at HSN.com. There they are offering it with TRIPLE minutes for life. The deal includes 1200 (total) minutes with the phone, for a total of $129.99. If you need a CDMA phone and don’t care about a QWERTY keyboard, the 290c is a good way to go in my opinion, especially if you plan to stay with TracFone for a while and can take advantage of that Triple Minutes deal. Click here and search for “LG 290c.” (Thanks to TracFancier for taking the time to point this one out to me!)

As I looked for the LG 290c, I also noticed that the LG 800g is still being sold at HSN with triple minutes for life as well. They had offered this deal previously, but those always sold out so fast that I never got chance to share the deal on the blog, or buy one for myself. Now after learning about the texting issues, I don’t want one. I’m a little surprised that they are still selling this phone when TracFone and Net10 themselves have stopped, and I would advise being cautious with this deal as well. With all the problems with texting, and the replacement EX124g phones causing people some headaches as well, it might not be worth the hassle to grab the 800g at this time.

However, the fact that there are now two TMFL phones raises the question of when TMFL will become widely available. Hopefully it won’t be long before we see it as a standard feature on new phones and as an upgrade card you can buy from TracFone for existing phones, as we previously saw with DMFL. If the roll-out sequence of DMFL is any indication, I would think that we’ll continue to see more of the most expensive TracFones come with TMFL standard, then over time we’ll see more and eventually all of their lineup including TMFL. Considering this, it might be worth waiting, if you can, before you buy another TracFone handset.

Straight Talk News – Samsung t528g Debuts, Nokia E71 and Nokia 6790 return

A couple of changes have taken place on Straight Talk’s site this week. I’ll deal with the less interesting items first. After a long time being unavailable from Straight Talk directly, both the Nokia E71 and the Nokia 6790 are once again showing up. You can check them out by clicking here. Take note, though, that if your local Walmart has these models in stock, you might want to check them out as the price may be cheaper in the store.

But most notably, the touch-screen Samsung T528g is also now available online. It’s priced at $99.99, and unlike those Nokia’s you can use it with the $30 plan. A couple of the noteworthy specs on this model include a 3.0-inch touch screen, 3G and WiFi, App-capable, and mp3 player.

To find this phone on Straight Talk’s site, click here.

And here’s the review index page for the Samsung t528g.

New Tracfone Promotional Codes and Other News

Here’s a link to the complete list: TracFone Promotional Codes
I went through the TracFone promo code list on July 6th, and there were VERY few changes this time around. Only one code expired since the last update, and I found only two new codes to add:

  • 86597 for 50 bonus minutes on a 200-minute card
  • 13062 for 200 bonus minutes on a 400-minute card

I added both of these codes to the database, in bold to show that they are new to the list.

I’m currently waiting on my EX124g to arrive so I can tear it open and start exploring it, and I’ve also got the LG 501c review underway. I don’t think I’ll finish up the 800g review, as it seems that it won’t be for sale any more and the text messaging problem seems like a fatal flaw anyway. But there is still plenty of new content coming soon.

It looks like the Samsung t404g, previously available for Straight Talk and Net10,  might be headed to TracFone soon as well. TracFancier pointed out that this model recently showed up on the TracFone “activate phone” page, which is rare for an older phone. So perhaps there will be another qwerty option for TracFoners.

Finally, and somewhat off-topic, I came across something else that I thought was worth sharing. Best Buy did a phone “Hall of Shame” review, complete with pictures of phones 20 years old. Check it out here. It reminds me of my first TracFone, the Nokia 5280 (I think).

What’s your oldest TracFone memory? I have a vague recollection of old StarTac handsets on TracFone, I think, but I can’t remember for sure. Please share your story in the comments below this post. If you can post pictures, that would be even better!

Motorola EX124g now available for TracFone

After much anticipation, TracFone is now selling the Motorola EX124g. The_Sweeper, TracFancier, and AmericanMutt all noticed this and posted it in the comments on various posts of this blog after TracFone put it up on their site earlier today.

Motorola EX124g is available from TracFone.comIt is listed at $79.99, and of course includes double minutes for life as well as all the other features we’ve been waiting for (touch screen, 3.0 mp camera, and mp3 player, to name a few). Use code GI2011 when you check out to save $5 off the list price. Click here to check it out now on TracFone.com.

Don’t forget, as I pointed out in my most recent post, that TracFone is sending out free EX124g’s to 800g owners that are having problems with text messaging. So you might be eligible to get upgraded to this one for free if you already bought the 800g recently.

Also, I don’t have any official word on when we’ll see this model for Net10 (or possibly Straight Talk as well), but I have to believe that it will be very soon, at least for Net10, based on a couple of things I’ve seen around the web.

I’ll be ordering this phone and putting it through my review process as I do with all phones, and I can assure you that this time it won’t take as long as it took me to get going with the 800g . Stay tuned for more. In the mean time, you can check out the Motorola EX124g review index page to see what others are saying about this phone in the comments, or check the TracFone site for more phone specs:

TracFone

Net10

Straight Talk

LG 800g Review – Important Info

Apparently there is a “known issue” with the LG 800g and how it handles text messaging. I haven’t experienced this personally, but I’ve seen problems mentioned in the comments on this blog, as well as on some other forums.

Problem with texting on the LG 800gThe most common complaint that I’ve seen is that people are getting the same message in their inbox many multiple times, while others have said that there messaging has stopped working altogether. Whatever the case, there is apparently some faulty programming in this phone. I haven’t figured out whether there’s any particular event that will trigger this problem but the bottom line is that this issue is, apparently, impossible to fix.

A couple of people have reported that TracFone has offered to replace their LG 800g free of charge … drumroll please … with a Motorola EX124g. There are a couple of significant conclusions to be drawn here, not necessarily in order of importance:

1. The problem with the 800g must be really bad if TracFone is replacing them with a differnt model. I think this is especially true with the 124g, which is expected to be a more expensive phone than the $50 800g.

2. If you already have an 800g, I would suggest that you relentlessly test the text messaging function to make sure it’s working properly and, if it’s not, call TracFone ASAP and hopefully you’ll get a replacement sent to you.

3. The Motorola EX124g will likely be available soon. While it’s possible that TracFone will send out the replacement handsets prior to the retail release of the EX124, I believe it is very unlikely considering that, in all my years of following TracFone, I’ve never heard of anyone getting their hands on a phone prior to its general release. And since I’m sure Tracfone won’t want to keep valued customers waiting (actually, I’m not sure on that, but it would be very rude!), I think they will probably be shipping those replacements pretty soon. So I think it’s a safe bet that the 800g will be available for sale.

4. The Motorola EX124g will be available on TracFone. I was previously uncertain as to whether it would be reserved only for the higher-volume plans of Straight Talk and Net10, but now TracFone users who have been holding out for the motorola can rejoice.

Further, the 800g has been pulled off the TracFone and Net10 sites for over a week now. Considering all this, I will probably pull back on my LG 800g review and related Q&A until the issue is cleared up, one way or another.

Finally, if you’ve had problems with texting on your LG 800g phone, please share your experience in the comments below this post.

Tomorrow, I’ll give a little more info about the Motorola EX124g.